Was Menger Aristotelian? A Rejoinder and Clarification - Aix-Marseille Université Access content directly
Journal Articles Cosmos and Taxis Year : 2022

Was Menger Aristotelian? A Rejoinder and Clarification

Gilles Campagnolo


How did Carl Menger read Aristotle? This debate is 'old hat' within Mengerian scholarship. Delving through the archives, new elements have been added by Emil Kauder and, more recently, by myself. Some issues raised by Ricardo Crespo are clarified in the following response. In an essay published in 2003, Crespo defended the idea that Menger is not an 'orthodox Aristotelian'. I retorted in a paper coauthored with Aurélien Lordon in 2011. Crespo resumed the exchange, summarized and modified his argument (Crespo 2022). This rejoinder aims at setting the record straight.
Fichier principal
Vignette du fichier
campagnolo_ct_vol10_iss5_6_final.pdf (182.29 Ko) Télécharger le fichier
Origin : Publisher files allowed on an open archive
Licence : CC BY NC ND - Attribution - NonCommercial - NoDerivatives

Dates and versions

hal-03896083 , version 1 (13-12-2022)


  • HAL Id : hal-03896083 , version 1


Gilles Campagnolo. Was Menger Aristotelian? A Rejoinder and Clarification. Cosmos and Taxis, 2022, 10 (5-6), pp.88-99. ⟨hal-03896083⟩
48 View
49 Download


Gmail Facebook X LinkedIn More